AI Versus Human Writing: What Is Better?

Jan 9, 2025 | Ghostwriting

Claim your Free E-Book

How to Hire a Ghostwriter

In the last couple of years, artificial intelligence – better known as AI – has infiltrated almost every segment of our daily lives. No matter where you travel in society you can find a conversation about how far AI will eventually go with tones ranging from the hopeful to downright dystopian. That conversation naturally extends to the writing world as well where everyone from writers to readers is curious about what happens in the AI versus human writing debate. 

Will real writers go away? Will AI take over? These questions, and others, spark the question: what happens in a real comparison, AI versus human writing.

Let’s first start by discussing why AI has become so prevalent in the writing world. In the simplest terms, programs like ChatGPT and others have made creating new, “original” text super easy. This is why developers refer to it as “generative AI”. These programs, available to anyone with an internet browser, are capable of creating new, original content off of prompts.

Here’s the part that makes AI writing even more tempting. Those AI programs can create that so-called original content, what might take a real writer hours, or even days, in a matter of minutes. 

As constructed, the key to making AI work (to some extent) is knowing how to enter effective prompts. This might become, in the near future, an art unto itself. Knowing the proper prompts and language necessary, allowing the generative program spit out precisely what you want it to. Cursory exploration of something like ChaptGPT shows us that there can be a world of difference in results.

Want to get the highest quality product from an AI writing program? You had better know exactly how to ask for what you’re looking for.

AI Versus Human Writing, erick mertz, ghostwriter, oregon city

AI Versus Human Writing: What Really Matters?

What really matters to you is how good those results are. Can something like ChatGPT really create professional level writing content, on a par with a top shelf writer? Whether you’re a reader and book lover, prospective writer, or a business person filling a content calendar, speed is only part of the issue. 

Are the results good enough to engage with readers? When it comes to the AI versus human writing debate, we’ll have to see. The jury on that is still out.

Jump onto any on-line or social media forum serving writers and they’ll all tell you that AI simply cannot do the same thing that a real writer does. While I instinctively agree (because, of course, I am a writer) this statement is, without evidence, baseless and likely more fueled by emotion.

Seeing how these claims are largely baseless without evidence, I thought it would be interesting to do a side by side comparison. What happens when you give a human writer and ChatGPT the same assignment? Does the AI create a credible piece of writing? Or is it still behind a human?

Let’s have the AI versus human writing debate with some examples.

Lets Make A Comparison

In this AI versus human writing experiment, I decided to work off of a very simple example. I imagined a basic scene involving two lovers. One that takes place in a basketball arena between a player and one of the halftime performers. The action centers on a crucial, late game free throw and a raucous crowd.

I concocted this example for three reasons. 

First, with the character and setting involved (the player shooting free throws, the halftime performer, and the player on the bench) the scene sets up a simple triangle. 

It’s the stuff of any romance novel.

Next, I chose the scenario because there are two very different sources of tension. One is the game itself which is close in score with two free throws coming that will decide the outcome. The other source of tension is the excitement between the player and the performer.

Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, the scene depicts that most human emotion: love.

AI Versus Human Writing

AI Versus Human Writing: The AI Results

Before I show you the results, let me explain the methodology. I used the free version of ChatGPT, which is openly available to anyone. 

I carefully crafted the writing prompt as follows:

Write me a 300-500 word scene that takes place late in a tightly contested, important basketball game in which one player is shooting crucial free throws while one of his teammates on the bench experiences a love at first sight moment with a halftime performer watching from the tunnel.

Here Is What The AI Came Up With

The Final Countdown

The air in the arena was electric, the kind of atmosphere that seemed to hang on the razor’s edge between euphoria and despair. The scoreboard read 98-97, with 11.2 seconds remaining. Sweat glistened on Corey “CJ” Jackson’s face as he stood at the free-throw line, bouncing the ball twice before catching his breath. He tried to block out the deafening chants from the opposing fans, the thunderous stomp-stomp-clap echoing like a heartbeat. It was just him, the hoop, and the ball.

From the bench, Malik, CJ’s teammate and closest friend, leaned forward, elbows on his knees, hands clasped together. But his focus wasn’t entirely on the game. Not anymore.

From the corner of his eye, he had caught a glimpse of her. She stood in the shadowy tunnel leading to the court, partially hidden behind a security guard. Her sequined outfit shimmered faintly under the fluorescent lights, the signature costume of the halftime dance crew. A single strand of loose curls framed her face, her features lit with a mix of curiosity and quiet intensity as she watched CJ step up to the line.

Malik’s heart thudded in his chest, drowning out the roar of the crowd. He couldn’t remember the last time he felt this kind of pull—raw, immediate, undeniable. It wasn’t just her beauty, though that was impossible to ignore. It was the way she stood there, a vision of calm in the storm, like she belonged to another world entirely.

“Focus up, Malik!” one of his teammates hissed, nudging him with an elbow.

Right. The game. But Malik’s eyes kept drifting back to her, helpless against the invisible thread that seemed to bind him to this stranger. She was biting her lower lip now, watching CJ’s every move like she had a stake in this moment too.

CJ exhaled sharply, raised the ball, and let it fly. The first free throw rattled around the rim before dropping in. The crowd erupted, but the home fans were a step louder, sensing a comeback still within reach.

CJ’s shoulders tightened as he received the ball for his second shot. Malik tried to refocus, but his gaze darted back to the tunnel. She was smiling now—relieved, maybe, or impressed—and he found himself smiling too, though he had no reason to.

“Yo, Malik, you good?” another teammate whispered, raising an eyebrow.

“Yeah. Yeah, I’m good,” Malik replied, though his voice was distant, almost dreamy. He straightened up, forcing himself to lock eyes on CJ. But the second CJ released the ball, Malik’s gaze flickered back to the tunnel.

Swish.

The sound of the net snapping was music to the ears of the away team, and CJ pumped his fist as the scoreboard ticked to 100-97. The timeout horn blared, and the team erupted into motion, huddling together for the final defensive stand.

As Malik joined the huddle, he stole one last glance at the tunnel. She was gone.

His heart sank, but only for a moment. Malik wasn’t the kind to believe in fate, but tonight, he decided, he might start.

What Happened There?

What ChatGPT created seemed fairly credible; at least at first glance. The generative AI concocted a scene that looked and felt like a real basketball game and it even created a secondary relationship between the shooter and a bench player. Making them friends adds an element of depth. 

I also liked that it avoided a particularly dubious sports fiction trope: the climactic moment comes with a big red 0.0 on the clock and the free throws take the team from behind to ahead. This scenario plays out more like a real basketball game. Nice work. 

On deeper examination, however, the scene reveals a few key problems.

While the point of view is surprisingly consistent, it doesn’t really reveal any emotion. The girl distracts Malik from the game happening on the court, but it’s all on a surface level. 

What are his deeper feelings about this moment where he sees this woman? As it’s written, the girl is objectified like a fairly generic romantic foil/stand in. After reading it, I don’t get a sense that their romance will yield any complications or depth. 

The passage is also wordy. Yes, it is true that I told it to write up to 500 words, but the instructions didn’t say where to end the scene. Written to capture a sequence that, in real life, takes all of thirty seconds, the writing drags on, not taking advantage of a situation that is rife with natural tension.

Lastly is the absence of details around the game or its potential importance. Is it the playoffs? Are the two teams rivals? On first read I thought, where are the colors of the uniforms and such? It’s like the AI omitted those intentionally so that this could be any basketball game instead of any specific game. 

AI Versus Human Writing: The Human Attempt

Before you read my piece, let me say, I wrote mine first. After crafting the prompt I would eventually give ChatGPT for the AI versus Human writing debate, I crafted my own version of the scene. 

I will also add this. I’m a basketball fan. Like a bona fide hoop head. I attend anywhere from 20-30 live basketball games a year and have since I was a kid. 

Here Is What The Human Came Up With

Donovan stepped to the free throw line. He managed to quiet the roar from the raucous home crowd in his head as he wiped the sweat from his brow and nodded. 

“Two shots,” the referee said. 

Donovan nodded. It all comes down to this. Up by three in the national championship game with less than ten seconds left on the clock. The team’s whole season rode on this moment, one that he had been preparing for his entire life.

The referee blew his whistle and passed Donovan the ball. He dribbled three times and paused before spinning the smooth leather in his hands. He had always felt at home holding a basketball. From the time when he was a little kid, shooting hoops in the front yard while waiting for his father to come home from work to hopefully join him. 

Donovan settled and let himself travel back in time. He bent his knees, eyed the rim, and put the ball up into the air–

SWISH.

He felt euphoria surge through him as the home crowd went crazy. Taking a step back, Donovan pumped his fist and mopped his brow again. He could hear the cheers from his teammates the bench. He had to focus.

Then he saw her. She was watching the game from the tunnel and, as their eyes met, he felt his heart skip a beat. 

“You ready?” the referee shouted over the delirious crowd.

Donovan nodded. But as he took the ball back, and started his pre-shot routine, all he could feel was her eyes piercing him from afar. Of all the games, of all the nights to show up. 

They had left things unresolved between them the last time. Why did she have to be here right now?  At a time when Donovan needed so badly to focus, he was forced to wonder. Was she coming to say goodbye? Or was it to say she was sorry.

Donovan bounced the ball. He eyed the rim and sharpened his focus as the arena bounced. He reminded himself: it’s just you, the ball and basket. It’s no different than it was all those years ago in the front yard. 

He bent his knees. With an eye on the rim, he rose out of his crouch and released the ball in a perfect arc–

The crowd went wild.

The referee whistled. Time out. 

Donovan stepped back as his excited teammates mobbed him. He stole a moment from the celebration to try and find her. Through the mayhem, he could see her celebrating with the rest of the crowd. 

Thank goodness. They were going to get another chance. This time they wouldn’t screw it up.

What Happened There?

I’m terrible at judging my own writing. I’ll leave some of that up to you. But let me explain some of my writing and inspiration process. Specifically, how I came to create this scene. 

I wrote this the day after going to a basketball game in person. It was an exciting, hotly contested game between two rivals and came down to the final shot. The player who made that final shot, in front of the home crowd, was a guy who, without going into too much depth, has been maligned throughout his young career.

Hitting that bucket? It was a huge moment for him.

Another element I brought to the page was my personal experience. I played in high school (nothing big; I was a benchwarmer) and still think about the feeling of a smooth leather basketball in my hands. There is something visceral about holding a basketball that brings up a lot of emotions for me. 

AI Versus Human Writing

AI Versus Human Writing: A Conclusion?

When it comes to creative writing, just like any other art form, quality is subjective. Some people love the gauzy feeling of a Kinkade painting, placing one over their dining room table, while others might cringe.

Beauty is forever in the eye of the beholder.

Two realizations come out of this little AI versus human writing experiment for me. The first is that, in its early generative form, AI plays it safe when it comes to writing. Because it creates without any personal experience to draw on it is forced to characterize and describe things it has never experienced. In this example, it’s taking a lot of disembodied basketball experiences and approximating what it thinks that moment looks and feels like. 

In the example, which should capture the dual heart-stopping moments of love and performance, the AI chose to emphasize setting over feeling. Is that because it has scanned and internalized enough data on basketball games that it became an easy place of emphasis? I don’t know. But reading the AI submission, I felt as though the writing was flat.

There certainly wasn’t anything particularly memorable in the writing. Isn’t that what story is supposed to offer us? Unforgettable moments?

The second realization is far more frightening. We are still in the relative infancy of readily available generative AI, like ChatGPT, which makes this capability just the tip of the iceberg. I know we’re teetering on the edge of science fiction here, but what happens when the generative powers reach toddler level? 

What about adolescence? Perhaps now the AI isn’t quite able to capture it, but we can look ahead, not too far, to a time when the AI versus human writing debate isn’t even realistic. 

What about tomorrow? The answer to the question is, who knows. Technology’s linear evolution can become disrupted and subverted, and with AI, we can almost be certain that the next thing is closer than we think and it will blow our minds.

The AI versus human writing debate is ever changing, but the real writer is here to stay. In a comparison between the two, something seems clear: while AI is able to generate competent text, you need something more than competent.

You need the best writing and for that, you need a real person.